Anti-Social Media

Every Friday I babysit for a family in Chestnut Hill. There are three awesome, well-mannered kids ages 8, 11, and 13. I am basically a glorified chauffeur, running the kids back and forth from school to practice to playdates. This past Friday I took on a slightly different role. I spent the entire evening hanging with a group of five eighth grade girls at the mall. My initial thought was how fun it might be to hear about all the latest middle school drama and see if it was similar to what me and my friends used to gossip about when we were that age—school teachers we all hated, sports teams we played on, and of course the cutest boys in the grade. Not to sound too much like one of those cliché parents who talks about how, when they younger, they “had to walk to school every day—uphill both ways,” but woah things have changed since I was in middle school.

I can say pretty confidently that even though the five girls were all in the same physical location, they spent a majority of their time interacting with people who were miles away from us. They relentlessly checked Snap Stories and Insta posts to keep tabs on the whereabouts and activities of all their peers. Most of the conversations—if they can even be considered that—consisted of deliberation over whether “Rachel and Sarah are at the mall together right now” because the artwork in the background of Rachel’s snap story is recognizably that of the inside of Chestnut Hill’s Forever 21 store. How much more obvious could Sarah and Rachel have been? Or, the fact that they think “Charlie really likes Avery” because scrolling through their Insta feed, one of the girls noticed that Charlie had tagged Avery in a funny meme post exactly 14 minutes ago.

Eight grade girls should really all be detectives.

phone die gif

It was a long night to say the least. Who knew a night of sitting around, watching teenagers be on their phones could be so draining? But it really got me thinking about the irony of “social” media and how there is really nothing social about it. Five girls hanging out, heads down in their phones, interacting with everyone except each other.

Social media has tricked us in a sense. If I was told that someone had upwards of 500 Facebook friends and then asked what that meant to me, the words “social butterfly” might come to mind. In the same vain, if I was told someone had 700 twitter followers, I would immediately think “Wow they must be socializing people all day.” But that’s where the true irony lies, the more “social” you are on these social platforms, the less actually social you are. There is only one true interaction taking place, and that is between you and your device’s screen.

When you think of social media, you think of the ability to connect with hundreds, even thousands of people with the click of a button. When you think about it though, the time you spend on these platforms are probably the moments you are making the least connections of all. You are alone in your room looking at Facebook pictures, your walking in-between classes checking your WhatsApp messages, your sitting on the T on your way to work with your head down immersed in the latest twitter debates.

My evening babysitting left me curious, so I looked up multiple studies focusing on the detrimental social impacts of the latest generation’s obsession with social media. A study conducted by the American Academy of Pediatrics concluded that there are some major implications for young teens. According to a recent poll, “22% of teenagers log on to their favorite social media site more than 10 times a day, and more than half of adolescents log on to a social media site more than once a day. Seventy-five percent of teenagers now own cell phones, and 25% use them for social media, 54% use them for texting, and 24% use them for instant messaging”(New York Behavioral Health). This means that the time unlike the former generation who spent their childhood splitting time between doing arts and crafts, building structures out with blocks, or hanging out with the other neighborhood kids, kids of the latest generation are splitting their time between their IPhones, IPads, and computer screens. A huge part of this generation’s social and emotional development is occurring online, and with that comes serious social implications.

Children using smartphones

Generation is doing less and less face-to-face communication meaning they aren’t learning vocal or visual cues to the same extent. If we do not learn these cues, we are not able to properly adjust our behavior in certain situations. This hinders one’s ability to build and maintain healthy relationships with people in our lives. Both social anxiety and social “awkwardness” are becoming more and more prevalent (New York Behavior Health).

So what do we do? Don’t get me wrong, I realize there are many upsides to the increase of technology and time spent “interacting” with our screens. We have clearly all seen and experienced the benefits of social media, so ripping the phones out of the hands of Generation X might do more harm than good. That being said, I think we do need to reevaluate a little bit. We need to recognize that the time spent staring at our screens is taking a real toll on social development. I think we need to call a spade a spade and give the term a more suitable name. My vote? “Anti-Social Media.”

 

7 comments

  1. I totally agree with your point about the “anti-social” aspects of social media. I think it’s really scary how much earlier kids are now being exposed to technology. Technology was definitely a part of my childhood, but I also spent a decent amount of time outside playing with my friends. Nowadays, smartphones and iPads and other new technological developments are everywhere, including the hands of people who are way too young to be exposed. I wonder what psychological effects technology is going to have future generations.

  2. I really like how you brought to light how social media is tricking us into thinking that the people with the most friends and followers are the most social. It is definitely not uncommon for people to measure popularity based on how many followers people have on Instagram. I definitely agree that this is not an accurate representation, as it is almost impossible to have a relationship with hundreds (sometimes thousands) of people. On another similar note, this makes me think of of how we view/compare celebrities, often judging their notability based on how many people follow them. With the recent ability for people to buy followers, social media makes it even easier for famous figures to make it look like they have a bigger following than they actually do.

  3. This is a really interesting point. I completely agree with Sherri. I feel like it’s not nearly to set limits on social media and technology for kids. I spent 90% of my time playing outside or at the beach when I was a kid. Maybe an hour of TV when I woke up or before I went to bed, but that was it. It’s becoming an issue. My niece is 2 and asks for the iPad. It will be interesting to see how the kids who are really young now interact with others. What happens when they have to actually socialize with others when they’re older? The value of a conversation is so important as a learning tool, and I’m wondering if these young kids will be able to hold a conversation about things that really matter, not just about what Rachel and Sarah are doing.

    1. Holly I think your take on social media is extremely relevant, and I couldn’t agree more with your opinion that the term “social media” is so ironic. In response to Brittany’s point on wondering how these kids will grow up and learn how to socialize with others I point to my own blog. With the explosion of dating apps, older generations are now relying on these platforms to find “the perfect match” and foster conversation. We are now searching for genuine connections via our screens. These apps are marketed as a way to create relationships, but I personally think they promote inauthentic ones, and individuals lose the real value in face-to-face conversations. I worry that this younger generation isn’t getting the same exposure we did, and as they grow up they will filter right into the next social platform to engage with their peers.

  4. I completely agree with your point. In class we talked about how kids used to spend their time watching tv and that social media is better than tv because at least there is some interaction. I agree with that point but I think you have brought up an important issue with that. We only used to watch tv when we were alone for a couple hours a day when we woke up/before bed. Now kids are ALWAYS on social media and it’s taking away from meaningful interaction when they are with their friends. If you ask me it was better to mindlessly watch tv for a couple hours a day but spend the rest of your time having fun with friends.

  5. Holly, I definitely agree that kids today have become too addicted to social media, such as in the case that we described in class where they Snapchat pictures of walls in order to keep their SnapStreak alive. However, I do think that social media can be beneficial for them, if done correctly. In my first blog post, I mentioned how when I was growing up my mom always condemned when I spent time scrolling through Facebook, but always encouraged me to text. With this in mind, I think that it’s important for kids today to use social media if and only if it’s actually furthering their “social” lives. So while I wouldn’t necessarily recommend stalking someone’s entire Facebook album, I would suggest that they send Snapchats and tag their friends in relevant Instagram or Facebook posts. It’s almost a way of saying “I’m thinking about you” and keeps friendships alive. We should encourage younger generations to actively use it to engage, rather than passively scrolling.

  6. It always kills me when undergraduate students in this class lament about “kids these days,” and are totally oblivious as to how they are so completely different than college students a decade ago. Honestly, it’s one of my favorite fringe benefits to teaching this class and it happens every semester! I have a 7th grade daughter — I get it.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: