Reddit: An Analysis of our Online Communities

 

Early on in class this year, we talked about how we have a tendency to associate with people similar to ourselves within our online communities. When this discussion occurred, my mind immediately turned to Reddit. Reddit was founded in 2005 in Medford, Massachusetts, and describes itself as “the front page of the internet.” It is a social news aggregation and discussion website where users can upvote, downvote, comment, and discuss posts, images, videos, and links. The website is divided in to “subreddits” that unite users that are passionate about similar subjects. For example, I am passionate about my favorite football team, the Green Bay Packers. On Reddit, I can subscribe to r/GreenBayPackers, and get the latest news on the Packers from links and posts other Packers fans have posted. I can discuss the team with other fans online across the world before, during, and after the game if I choose to do so.

70bdbbafb108a4d4d28af794b02f34ab--packers-baby-packers-football.jpg

This format presents incredible opportunities for people to connect with others across the world with similar mindsets. If you are interested in trying to home brew a beer, but are not sure how, there are thousands of subscribers on r/homebrewing ready and willing to discuss steps, recipe ideas, what equipment they used, or anything else you would be interested to know. This format extends for thousands of different passions across the world, with everything from gardening to music to computer building, and many others. Imagine what we could learn by uniting our common knowledge (wisdom of the crowds, anyone?) on subjects like chemistry, mathematics, etc. With the enormous potential of a platform like this, I decided to look in to Reddit further and see how it has been used as a platform, and analyze the implications of such an online community, as well as analyze what some of the most popular subreddits are and what that says about our online society.

To date, Reddit’s platform has been used for a multitude of different purposes, both good and bad. One of the shining moments in Reddit history was when President Barack Obama hosted an “AMA” (Ask Me Anything) session on the site back in 2012. Reddit users from around the country were able to ask the President any question they wanted, and have the opportunity to have the President answer them directly. The President answered a multitude of questions, such as “What was the most difficult decision you had to make during this term?” and “How are you going to help small businesses in 2013 and 2014?” After the experience, the President claimed that it was “an example of how technology and the internet can empower the sorts of conversations that strengthen our democracy.” Other notable Reddit AMA’s include Bill Gates, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, and astronaut Chris Hadfield, who did a Reddit AMA while onboard the International Space Station.

Obama-Not-Bad-memegenerator

Of course, on a website that is essentially run by its users (due to their control of what stories are seen or not through upvotes and downvotes), every moment in Reddit’s history has not exactly been rosy. One of the worst moments in Reddit’s history was the site’s reaction to the Boston Marathon bombing. Many users of the site took it upon themselves to aid in the manhunt for the bombers, analyzing photos that the FBI was releasing and doing whatever else they could from behind their screens to try to identify the bombers. In terms of analyzing the photos released by the FBI, one Redditor claimed “I would rather have 10,000 [Redditors] than one FBI guy.” While the wisdom of the crowds is positive and helpful in many situations, in this case Reddit’s fervor went horribly wrong. Not surprisingly, a bunch of people behind their computer screens with no experience, inside knowledge, or expertise got the wrong guy. The community falsely identified Brown University student Sunil Tripathi as the second suspect. The student had been missing since March, and the Tripathi family was subjected to days of accusations online. They were even forced to take down the Facebook page dedicated to their son’s safe return. Tripathi was later found dead. This occasion showed the dangers of anyone being able to publish anything, and the ability to have it widely distributed, unverified, at rapid speed.

reddit-screenshot-boston.jpg

The implications of this community are very clear. The ability to unite people with similar opinions and passions opens up the potential for great conversation, progression, and growth. However, the nature of the site being open to anyone, and the breadth of distribution of the posts being left fully to the democracy of users, means there is potential for inaccurate or undesirable posts to achieve widespread viewership and engagement. The wisdom of the crowds can be fantastic in terms of occasions such as educational developments, but can very quickly go very poorly, as it did during the Boston Marathon bombing.

Outside of these few notable examples, what does day to day life on Reddit look like? What are we using this platform for on a daily basis, and what does that say about our online society? To answer this question, I went to a list of the most popular subreddits in order to see what most people were looking to obtain out of the site. The most subscribed subreddits, perhaps unsurprisingly, are a mix of things that further our knowledge, and memes/pictures/entertainment that we can use to waste away some time on our computers or phones. Within the top 20 subreddits, there are subreddits such as r/funny, r/gaming, r/aww, and r/movies. However, r/todayilearned, r/worldnews, r/askscience, and r/books are all also within the top 20. I think this dispersion is a good representation of what we as a society use the internet for in general. We certainly use the internet in order to further our education, learn something new, keep up with the world, and enhance our knowledge. At the same time, we as a society also spend a lot of time playing online games, looking at funny accounts on social media, and other things online that serve little but to help pass the time. It will be interesting to see how the Reddit community will continue to evolve.

10 comments

  1. Great post! I have found that Reddit is a great source of information. But like you said, many posts have to be taken with a grain of salt. Many people are quick to judge and make untrue statements but I would hope that other users would see the mistakes made and down vote these posts.

  2. Nice post! It’s crazy to think that Reddit is over a decade old! I thought you did a great job analyzing the pros and cons of such a platform. Reddit, like other internet forums, has had to deal with a lot of criticism about the kinds of content that its users produce. It seems that it has been relatively responsive, pulling down subreddits that are controversial in nature. However, drawing the line between free speech and hate speech has become a heated debate in regards to the website which is the 4th highest visited website in the U.S. and 8th in the world. It will be interesting to see how Reddit evolves with the new redesign and the rumors that it will go public as a company by 2020.

  3. Very in-depth post, great job! I’ve never used Reddit but I am now interested to peruse the website for information about some of my own interests and hobbies. I actually like the upvote downvote system, as I feel it usually self regulates the best material, at least in my own experience.

  4. I also reflected back on the interaction between Reddit users and the Boston Marathon bombing when we brought up crowd sourcing in class. I must admit I am intrigued by Reddit– it is really the perfect example of bringing out the very “best” and “worst” in society. I honestly feel that at least part of a class should be dedicated to debating Reddit and all the implications about the freedoms of the Internet, being able to express yourself anonymously, etc. I feel like it is an amazing tool (also the fact that is pretty “low tech” but has a huge online following), and also the fact that it has been extraordinarily useful as a political tool (as both a “public square” where you can discuss candidates around the world, and also by politicians as you said above). Great post!

  5. Great post! My brother is an avid reddit user and always used it to disseminate relevant news in our house before theSkimm or Morning Brew took off. Reddit actually announced yesterday that the company is considering filing for an IPO: https://www.axios.com/reddit-ceo-sets-sights-on-ipo-2509170177.html. Regarding the wisdom of the crowds, it is interesting to see how reddit functions similar to a page for a hashtag on Twitter. However, reddit hasn’t garnered as much public criticism in terms of allowing itself as a space for hate speech or political advertising. It’ll be interesting to see how the IPO affects the popularity of the site (especially as Twitter’s popularity continues to dwindle.)

  6. NIce post. I find Reddit to be a fascinating example because it was really an also-ran to Digg, until Digg absolutely imploded. Just goes to show that it’s hard to stay on top of the pile with so many gunning for you. https://www.technologyreview.com/s/428520/why-did-reddit-succeed-where-digg-failed/

  7. Great post. I enjoy using Reddit, especially when it comes to following sports (the Knicks) and reading about how others feel about the team before, during, and after each match. While sharing opinions with people across the nation and around the world is a powerful tool, I do agree with you that we have to tread waters carefully when it comes to sensitive issues like the Boston Marathon Bombing. I remember that day well, and remember everybody in BC being furious – we all wanted to go out and catch the person responsible. I wasn’t personally involved in trying to identify the suspect, but the Tripathi accusation was real – and I believed it briefly, due to all the hype surrounding him. I can’t imagine how much pain and suffering the Tripathi family had to go through as a result of the wisdom of the crowds which materialized through Reddit.

  8. Reddit is great. I know there has been some light controversy over some now banned subreddits. In every platform of social media, there are the good places where people exchange knowledge but also the bad places where hate speech can spawn. Reddit has been pretty successful so far in banning these subreddits but its always a slippery slope. Social media always seems to have the good with the bad.

  9. I had no idea that Reddit was founded in Mass–what a great fact! I use Reddit once in awhile, but I never knew the negative incidents that surrounded the platform during the Boston Marathon Bombing. Your post was insightful and informative, and it’s always important to take everything you read lightly–just because it’s on the internet, doesn’t make it true. Great blog post!

  10. Great post, Brian. Growing up in the area, I remember the manhunt which took place only two towns over from where I lived. The news was constantly referring back to the online community that was “assisting,” but the consequences of that were fairly serious as we can see in hindsight. I’ve personally found reddit to be a really great resource for things like new technology help, sports information, and the AMAs are always entertaining and insightful. Thanks for sharing!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: